Lucky Me by Robert Caisley is a light-hearted romantic comedy set in Denver, Colorado, entirely within Sara’s apartment. The story follows the seemingly unlucky Sara and her developing relationship with her new neighbour, Tom—raising the question of whether she can turn her luck around long enough to make it work.
This was my first encounter with the play, and the title alone was enough to spark curiosity. Although firmly set in Colorado, it’s one of those pieces that could easily travel— with a few small tweaks, it could just as comfortably sit in the UK. That said, the director and cast chose to stay true to the original setting, and credit to them: the American accents were well sustained throughout, which is no small ask over the course of a full performance.
The play opens with what appears to be a power cut—something that quickly becomes a recurring theme and a neat reflection of Sara’s ongoing run of bad luck. From a technical perspective, this is not a simple show to stage. Timed lighting shifts, practical effects like dripping water, and the general coordination required could easily go wrong, but the technical team handled it all with confidence. Everything landed as it should, which in a show about luck, felt particularly fitting.
The first half takes a little time to find its rhythm, but the second half really comes into its own—helped in no small part by the arrival of Yuri, played by Sam Evans. His performance brought a fresh energy and a welcome lift in pace, creating a character that was both convincing and very likeable.
There were also some thoughtful touches throughout. The inclusion of a programme page exploring symbols of good and bad luck added a nice layer, and details on stage—like the Lucky Charms cereal subtly changing as Sara’s fortunes shift—showed real attention to storytelling.
And then there’s the moment that’s hard to forget: Noel Redfern as Leo… eating the goldfish. It’s one of those scenes that catches you completely off guard—equal parts shocking and darkly comic. All you can really say is it was definitely Friday the 13th for poor Frank.
Overall, this was an enjoyable and well-executed production, with strong performances, clever technical work, and a clear sense of fun. A show that grows into itself and leaves you with a few memorable moments—some of which you might not quite unsee!
Reviewed by – Emma T.
Comments are closed